Connect with Healthcetera
Saturday, June 7, 2025
HomeStandard Blog Whole Post (Page 344)

Whistleblowing nurses Vicki Galle and Anne Mitchell

Whistleblowing nurses Vicki Galle and Anne Mitchell

Two nurses, Anne Mitchell and Vicki Galle, blew the whistle on physician Rolando Arafiles for a variety of charges that included unprofessional conduct at Winkler County Memorial Hospital in what they thought was a confidential report to the state board for medicine.  Instead of the physician being investigated, the nurses found themselves the target of unprofessional conduct brought by the physician’s friends, Sheriff Robert Roberts and County Attorney Scott Tidwell, and were fired from their jobs by hospital adminstrator Stan Wiley.  The charges were dropped for Galle and Mitchell was acquited by a jury that deliberated for one hour. Now Roberts, Tidwell and Wiley (who resigned from his position at the hospital in October) have been indicted for retaliating against the whistleblowers.

This is very good news for patients. Nurse must be able to report physicians, administrators, or other health care providers (including other nurses) who are unsafe or engaging in illegal activities, then patients will not be safe.  These nurses went through hell after doing what they knew was in the best interests of patients and the hospital would not take action against the physician. It cost them their jobs, crippled them financially, and besmirched their reputations. Nurses I spoke with said that if they didn’t get exonerated and if those involved in the retaliation were not held accountable, it would make them think twice about reporting unsafe practices. Here’s hoping the jury throws the book on these three fellows for their retaliation and potentially jeopardizing the interests of the public.

Diana J. Mason, PhD, RN, FAAN, Rudin Professor of Nursing

 

[caption id="attachment_10559" align="alignleft" width="300"] Whistleblowing nurses Vicki

movie-posterOne of the most powerful and influential tools of the modern world is the media, which can be used to spread awareness, ideas, and opinions, impacting common attitudes and policies. Now, imagine radio and television stations controlled by tens of thousands of school teachers, students, housewives, farmers, and indigenous communities. This was the historic occurrence in the non-violent uprising during the summer of 2006, in Oaxaca, Mexico. “A Little Bit of So Much Truth” is a documentary that captured this event, which occurred when the people of Oaxaca took 14 radio stations and one TV station into their own hands, using them to organize and defend their grassroots struggle for social, economic, cultural, and political justice.

This film begins with the atrocious conditions in Oaxaca—pollution, racism against indigenous peoples, lack of water, scarcity of food, and no security. Frustrated with their living conditions, the teachers of Oaxaca went on strike and created their own radio station, Radio Plantón, through which they expressed their discontent and opinions about needed government change, mainly the immediate resignation of their corrupt governor, Ulises Ruiz Ortiz.

The federal government retaliated against this strike, sending troops to attack the radio station. Yet, despite having trained military personnel and weapons, the federal government was unable to take control of the radio station due to civilian resistance—through the use of the radio, the people of Oaxaca were able to organize themselves and successfully resist. Soon after this initial conflict, the teachers formed the Popular Assembly of the Peoples of Oaxaca (APPO, from its Spanish name, Asamblea Popular de los Pueblos de Oaxaca.). Following several more attacks from the federal government, the APPO took over yet another radio station, Radio Universidad. The radio continually proved its importance as it saved lives by giving rapid, current information during shoot-outs and air raids. Aside from radio, the APPO also took over a government run television station because of their belief that the two main channels, TV Azteca and Televisa, were manufactoring mass opinions without truly informing viewers.

Beginning with a simple radio station in a small town, this movement turned into a seven month conflict involving the federal government and multiple states in Mexico. Whether the civilian takeover of the media was justified or not, this film highlights the impact that the media has on people. Media outlets, like the radio or television, have massive potential for any use, which can be beneficial and dangerous at the same time. Television advertisements can sell harmful drugs one second and the next present anti-smoking commercials. In order to tip the scale towards healthier information—how to fight obesity, drug addiction, human rights abuses—health professionals need to flood the mainstream media with ads. By mainstream, I mean not just television or radio, but social networking sites like Facebook, Twitter and YouTube, whose exposure exceeds that of television or radio, at no cost.

Inspired by the influence of Radio Plantón, I think more people should be involved—either by active participation or by paying attention—in the media. As proven by the influence of Radio Plantón the more informed we are, the better.

 

Jennifer De Jesus is a student in the Macaulay Honors College at Hunter and an avid movie watcher. She is also an employee of the Health Professions Education Center, which has one of the largest collection of health films in the New York City area.

One of the most powerful and influential

Amy Berman, RN

Amy Berman, RN

Amy Berman is a registered nurse and Senior Program Officer at the John A. Hartford Foundation who has just gone public with the news that she has been diagnosed with an incurable breast cancer that has metastasized. She shares her experience with seeking information about treatment options and how some of the health care providers with whom she interacted were incredibly dismissive of her goals. Her story is on the John A. Hartford Foundation’s blog, Health AGEnda (the foundation focuses on improving the health care of older adults), and includes her commitment to using her remaining time in this life to “call on our health care institutions and professionals to make a real commitment to listening to their patients.” She points out that this is about “patient-centered care“–something that her experience painfully illustrates is too often empty rhetoric.  This is MUST reading and sharing with anyone who cares about the failings of our health care system and EVERY health care provider. Amy will continue to blog about her experiences and perspectives.

Diana J. Mason, PhD, RN, FAAN, Rudin Professor of Nursing

[caption id="attachment_10448" align="alignleft" width="80"] Amy Berman, RN[/caption] Amy