Connect with Healthcetera
Wednesday, November 13, 2024
HomeStandard Blog Whole Post (Page 76)

On a hot Washington Thursday, June 22, a group of health care professionals and students in white coats descended on Capitol Hill to protest the proposed American Health Care Act (AHCA)

This new Act would replace the current Affordable Care Act. President Trump was quoted as saying that the House-passed health care reform bill as being a “mean” health insurance bill. The AHCA would leave almost 24 million uninsured. Nurses, physicians and other [health] professionals stood tall at this press conference.  House Minority leader Nancy Pelosi, Congressman Raul Ruiz, a physician from California and Congressman Steny Hoyer from Maryland [were] in attendance.

The vehemence with which this group expressed their displeasure with the bill was refreshing.  We heard physician after physician speak of the horrors and dangers of having no insurance, the consequences of which we all have seen in many patients who deserve better.  Possible victims include: elderly patients in nursing homes, whose costs represent 42% of the Medicaid dollar (nursing home residents account for about 6% of Medicaid enrollees); women seeking gynecological care; pregnant women whose pregnancy may now be defined as a preexisting condition; children on Medicaid, which covers 40% of all children; and disabled individuals living in facilities covered by Medicaid.  All will be vulnerable. 

The [health care] group continued to voice the mantra, “Do no harm” and speakers addressed the harms of this proposed bill would have if passed. Passage of this bill would devastate a population that finally received health insurance through the ACA, after many years of poor or delayed care. Today’s American population is aging.  The proposed legislation would turn the clock back for the elderly, women and children toward failed “uncompensated care” pools.  We spoke of people with conditions that are preventable or curable if picked up under current routine preventive care (“essential health benefits”), which could disappear under the new law by 2019. 

GW Nursing students who attended the briefing share their reactions about attending:

Kari Deakins:

As a student, it was very inspiring to be able to stand shoulder to shoulder with providers of the interdisciplinary team to share our disagreement with the new AHCA. Our patients will be from many socioeconomic backgrounds in the future, and we must ensure that vulnerable populations are protected. The newly proposed AHCA risks the loss of health care benefits to millions of Americans, the possible denial of future benefits to millions more. It was motivating to listen to our future colleagues and physicians tell countless stories about their patients who would be affected by this damaging legislation. We must be vigilant and active as students to protect our patients and those that who need our help, and as we move into our practice and nursing careers, we must remain proactive in the advocacy of our patients.”  

Jennifer Kanelos:

“Participating in the white coat press conference was one of the most inspiring and memorable days I’ve had at GW to date. Gathering on Capitol Hill with nurses, physicians and med students united in the belief that all Americans deserve access to affordable health coverage, left an impact on me that will last a lifetime. From day one, we learn at GW SON to provide patient centered care focused on evidence based research. The facts are unequivocal, denying millions of people health coverage like the AHCA would do, will have devastating results on our ability to provide care for those that need it most.

I am halfway into my nursing education, and something in me has changed for the better. My experience at GW and with patients in the clinical rotations, have given me a new outlook on the world. I see people and our country differently now, and standing among so many providers with the Capitol and Washington Monument behind us, I truly felt like I belonged to something bigger than myself. Energized by the passion and commitment of the speakers and elected officials, I became a healthcare advocate that day. I look forward to a lifetime of speaking out on behalf of my patients, working towards a more perfect union, and maybe even one day asking for your vote”.

We were all there to prevent the devastating effects of the AHCA. We cannot afford to harm the American people with this bill, which would dismantle care that had finally become a reality for so many. As health care professionals we must DO NO HARM!

 

 

Update: On Tuesday, June 27, Senate Republican leaders bowed to pressure from within their own ranks and postponed a vote to overhaul the Affordable Care Act until after the Fourth of July recess. 

This post is written by George Washington University faculty member Joyce Pulcini, PhD, RN, PNP-BC, FAAN, with contributions by Kari Deakins and Jennifer Kanelos, George Washington University School of Nursing students who attended the action. Dr. Joyce is a member of the National Advisory Council at the Center for Health Policy and Media Engagement.

On a hot Washington Thursday, June 22,

Language and framing are critically important to public debates about policy. The Better Care Reconciliation Act of 2017 is an example of framing that tries to obscure what is really going on.

The BCRA is the Senate’s version of a bill to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare. Let’s start with the language of “Obamacare”. The language used to name the Affordable Care Act (ACA) was a deliberate attempt to garner support for a law that would increase health coverage but also make other changes in the health care system to “bend the cost curve” of health care spending. “Obamacare” was the term used by those who opposed it and who opposed the presidency of Barack Obama. They thought that linking the law with Obama would cause some people to oppose it on principle. In fact, a number of people who had benefited from the ACA but said they opposed “Obamacare” didn’t know that the two were the same thing. This may account for the increasing popularity of the ACA as Congress and President Trump now try to repeal it.

Now consider the BCRA. What would get better with this bill? What gets worse? Who benefits, who loses?

  • Perhaps, some like that it would eliminate the individual mandate to have health insurance. But that will lead to higher premiums for everyone once they need health coverage and try to buy it. The Senate has just modified the bill to reduce the likelihood that younger, healthy people will eschew paying for insurance until they are sick. The modification is that individuals who have a break in their insurance coverage will have to wait six months before signing up for coverage.
  • Some may like that it will end Medicaid, as we know it. But this will have such detrimental effects on all of us that the opposition is growing. The bill goes farther than the House version of the repeal effort (called the American Health Care Act) by more drastically cutting Medicaid funding and allowing states to opt for block grants with spending caps. It is estimated that 40% of our nation’s children are on Medicaid. And their parents are likely the working poor, unable to afford other coverage.
  • While rural areas largely voted for Trump and a Republican Congress with their promise to repeal Obamacare, few realize that many rural hospitals depend upon the increase in people with health coverage under the ACA, including the Medicaid expansion. Under both the House and Senate version of the repeal bills, the number of uninsured people will rise to more than 20 million. When this coverage is drastically reduced through cuts in Medicaid and other changes that the BCRA will bring about, we’ll once again see an uptick in the closure of rural hospitals. Their financial margins are so thin that even small increases in the uninsured will strain emergency rooms, increase the rate of uncompensated care, and accelerate the economic decline of many rural communities when they lose this important community service.
  • The BCRA would get rid of the requirement for a minimum essential benefits package that must be covered by any insurance plan. Some folks like this, saying that they shouldn’t have to pay for someone’s maternity care or substance abuse treatment. But how do we know ahead of time what benefits we might need?
  • Others want to see a lowering of taxes for Americans. The bill reduces government spending on health care and will enable the Republican Congress and the president to lower taxes, particularly for the wealthy. So those who are well off will benefit. Those who are poor and middle class will not.

What is “better” in this bill? It is being framed as a better way to reduce government spending and increase tax breaks for Americans. What may not be fully realized by those who support the bill is that it does so directly on the backs of the poor and middle class but will affect our entire nation. It will not produce better care.


Image source: http://english.tutorvista.com/literary-response/euphemism.html

Language and framing are critically important to

Senior Fellow Carole R. Myers PhD brings her health policy expertise to the airwaves twice a month to NPR’s Morning News on 91.9 FM WUOT in Knoxville, TN. Here’s the program write up from WUOT’s website where you can listen to her the segment:

 

 

This week marks the launch of a new series, HealthConnections. The brainchild of University of Tennessee associate professor Dr. Carole Myers, HealthConnections will bring the often-abstract world of health care, coverage and policy to a human level. What is access? How do marketplaces work? What’s the future of health insurance?

Dr. Myers and WUOT’s Brandon Hollingsworth will sort through these issues and more, all to give you a toolbox for understanding what you hear on the news, or to separate fact from fiction in the health care debate.

In the premiere episode, Dr. Myers and Hollingsworth introduce the series and get up to speed on the American Health Care Act, the GOP’s possible replacement for the Affordable Care Act.

What’s on your mind? On Twitter, send your questions to @wuotfm, or send an email to newsroom [at] wuot.org and use “HealthConnections” as your subject line.

Congratulations Carole! The entire team at the Center applaud you on this new platform where you will report on health policy.

Senior Fellow Carole R. Myers PhD brings